the lack of critical thinking?
May. 11th, 2004 10:19 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
anotheranonI ran across this article on Slashdot as part of a comment on a discussion about pseudoscience: Sesame Street, Epistemology, and Freedom, an essay on the lack of formal training in abstract and critical thinking.
It reminded me of a phone conversation I had with my sister. She lives in a conservative area and gets very frustrated by people around her who uncritically accept what they're told and go about their lives without ever having a creative, original, or "abnormal" thought.
She calls them "muggles" and derides them as stupid and I tried to explain to her (with doubtful effect) that they're not dumb, they just never learned. The article describes how the total of most people's exposure to formal critical thinking skills is in the Sesame Street skit "One Of These Things Is Not Like The Others", and suggests that many people never progress beyond kindergarten-level abstract thought, hobbling their efforts to make decisions and evaluate information in adulthood. It's an interesting possibility, especially reading it so soon after "President of Good and Evil", which suggests that George Bush suffers this very same deficiency of reasoning skills.
Disclaimer: I'm not going to be a snob and suggest that I've got spectacular reasoning skills and am somehow "better" - like many people I fall into the habit of only paying attention to information I agree with or like. I do try, however, to see all sides of an argument or issue; if I did learn anything beyond "OOTTINLTO" it wasn't until well after childhood, when my dad encouraged me to always question whether a source of information was worth my time or valid, and what perspective the source is coming from, but it's not as if he ever sat me down with the evening paper and made me go through each headline weighing it's biases and flaws (though perhaps he should have).
Like my sister, I am frustrated by ineptitude and lack of inquisitiveness, but unlike her I think it's just a lack of training, not something innate.
It reminded me of a phone conversation I had with my sister. She lives in a conservative area and gets very frustrated by people around her who uncritically accept what they're told and go about their lives without ever having a creative, original, or "abnormal" thought.
She calls them "muggles" and derides them as stupid and I tried to explain to her (with doubtful effect) that they're not dumb, they just never learned. The article describes how the total of most people's exposure to formal critical thinking skills is in the Sesame Street skit "One Of These Things Is Not Like The Others", and suggests that many people never progress beyond kindergarten-level abstract thought, hobbling their efforts to make decisions and evaluate information in adulthood. It's an interesting possibility, especially reading it so soon after "President of Good and Evil", which suggests that George Bush suffers this very same deficiency of reasoning skills.
Disclaimer: I'm not going to be a snob and suggest that I've got spectacular reasoning skills and am somehow "better" - like many people I fall into the habit of only paying attention to information I agree with or like. I do try, however, to see all sides of an argument or issue; if I did learn anything beyond "OOTTINLTO" it wasn't until well after childhood, when my dad encouraged me to always question whether a source of information was worth my time or valid, and what perspective the source is coming from, but it's not as if he ever sat me down with the evening paper and made me go through each headline weighing it's biases and flaws (though perhaps he should have).
Like my sister, I am frustrated by ineptitude and lack of inquisitiveness, but unlike her I think it's just a lack of training, not something innate.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2004-05-13 06:37 am (UTC)Yes, I have students who are so painfully shy that they never speak all semester. Others are in such a religious environment at home that they can't write without putting in references to Jesus and God -- indeed, they don't see any point in doing research in science because "God made everything, so we don't need to ask why." Others are frightened to leave South Dakota because "out there" they know that "bad things happen." Granted, not all small town students are like that -- I have met some really stellar minds! But overall in the demographic that I'm teaching, they are socially stunted compared to a young man or woman living in the city. On the other hand, they are very kind and sweet and are the least *jaded* students I've ever met.
no subject
Date: 2004-05-13 08:29 pm (UTC)I't sgood I have you to report these things as a reality check - I'm facing up to the fact that where I live and the people I'm friends with lets me often forget that there really are people as sheltered as your students still out there!
I hope that you're able to broaden more of your students minds, and I certainly hope that a wider world doesn't have to lead to jadedness for them. I'm also glad to learn you have some students you're proud of - that must be very rewarding :)